No Way to Run a Railway: HS2 and Policy-Making (Michael Ward)

Michael Ward kindly sent me this short paper about HS2 and the “policy-making” process surrounding it. Whilst I personally do not agree with his conclusions, his critique of the process is well worth reading. CT 

The case for High Speed Rail: a regional, social and economic perspective Continue reading

Posted in Whitehall | Leave a comment

Greece again

with Greece in the news again, those who haven’t already might want to read my analysis of the background to their fiscal crisis here.

 

Posted in Whitehall | Leave a comment

The Work Programme: individual versus systemic outcomes

The government is very proud of its Work Programme. It is especially proud of the fact that the WPs private sector providers are only paid on the basis of individual outcomes – do the participants get a “long term” job. Continue reading

Posted in Public Administration, Spending, Whitehall | 3 Comments

Spending Review 2012 – maybe

With most economists now forecasting that Britain will officially re-enter recession in Q1 2012, the Chancellor will be under immense pressure by the time of the Budget on 21st March to at least be seen to be doing ‘something’ about the economy. Continue reading

Posted in Whitehall | Leave a comment

The Evolution of Intellectual Freedom

I thought this was worth sharing……..

Posted in Whitehall | Leave a comment

Re-Centering the State? Pulling Arms-Length Bodies back into the Centre

A new report from the National Audit Office examines the British governments attempts to reorganise “arms-length bodies” in the UK. One of the central conclusions is that the reorganisation is dragging many of the functions of these bodies back to the ‘centre’ and closer to political control – in other words a big shift from quasi-autonomy back to hierarchical control. This is being achieved by either abolishing bodies and absorbing functions back into Ministries, or changing the status of the bodies. I reprint below the NAO’s own short summary of their findings, but the whole report is worth reading.

One final note: the Report contains nothing about the abolition of the NAO’s “sister” body the Audit Commission (as David Walker has pointed out). A very curious omission. Continue reading

Posted in Whitehall | Leave a comment

Old Wine in New Bottles? Logging the Name Changes in Government

There is often more continuity between themselves and their predecessors than any new Government cares to admit. One way they seek to disguise these continuities is to change the names of things, with minimal change to the actual thing itself, whether it’s a policy, a system or an organisation. Continue reading

Posted in Whitehall | 2 Comments

Implement That

Watch out for the word “implementation” in 2012. It’s the new in-word in Whitehall. Continue reading

Posted in Politics, Public Administration, Public Management, Whitehall | 1 Comment

Leadership in the Civil Service: Those that Can, Do Policy. Those That Can’t…..

Today (20 Jan 2012) the Public Administration Select Committee (PASC) published a scathing attack on the re-organisation at the top of the Civil Service that took place over Christmas. Continue reading

Posted in Public Administration, Whitehall | 2 Comments

Dangerous SNP Hubris Over Referendum

Does the SNP really want a free, democratic, Scotland? If so they are everything they can to ensure it may, just, become independent but is unlikely to be a genuine democracy. Continue reading
Posted in Whitehall | 2 Comments

My Top Ten (most read) WhitehallWatch posts of 2011 (so far)

Continue reading

Posted in International, Performance, Political Economy, Politics, Public Administration, Public Management, Spending, Whitehall | Leave a comment

Cuts in the City: How Manchester Fared in 2011

Tonight (Thursday 22) and tomorrow the BBC Radio 4 PM programme will carry items by reporter Andrew Bomford about how greater Manchester has fared over the past year in the face of a sluggish economy and large public spending cuts. It’s based on a report we wrote for them on the impact of the cuts (which you can get here). Continue reading

Posted in Whitehall | Leave a comment

Academy Schools Funding System Fails – quelle surprise

I have been predicting for some time that some of the big structural changes to public services are likely to destabilise the financial systems in health, education and local government. So it comes as no surprise that tens of millions of pounds have been ‘accidentally’ awarded to new Academy Schools.  Continue reading

Posted in Public Administration, Public Management, Spending, Whitehall | Leave a comment

We Are Not “All In It Together” – it’s official

Inequality across the OECD is rising, including in Britain, even before the impact of the current crisis has even worked its way through, an important new OECD report shows. Continue reading

Posted in Whitehall | Leave a comment

George Osborne’s Autumn Statement: We’re All Doomed

George Osborne’s “Autumn Statement” is certainly not a Pre Budget Report, as he promised it would not be. Instead, it is much more like a mini-Budget or even, given the timescales involved in many announcements, a mini-Spending Review. Continue reading

Posted in Whitehall | 1 Comment

Leadership of the British Civil Service: All Change?

Last week I gave evidence – alongside Professor Lord Peter Hennessy and Professor Tony Dean –  to the Public Administration Select Committee in Parliament on the changes taking place at the top of the UK Civil Service. The uncorrected minutes of the evidence session can be found here.

Other evidence sessions and the terms of reference and other information for the PASC inquiry can be found on their website here.

I also have articles examining different aspects of these changes appearing in Public Finance and Public Servant magazines over the next few weeks.

Posted in Whitehall | Leave a comment

Confusion and Denationalisation at the centre of the Health and Social Care Bill

I reprint below an excellent briefing by Professor Allyson Pollock and colleagues on key clauses of the Health and Social Care Bill.

It addresses two critical issues:

  • The removal of  legal responsibility from the Secretary of State to prove health services and
  • The confusing mixture of ‘person-based’ and ‘area-based’ arrangements for patients (and consequently funding arrangements – something I’ve brought up here before).

Continue reading

Posted in Whitehall | 3 Comments

Evidence Session: PASC to question academics and journalists about Head of the Civil Service role

Public Administration Select Committee - Announcement

EVIDENCE SESSION: PASC TO QUESTION ACADEMICS AND JOURNALISTS ABOUT HEAD OF THE CIVIL SERVICE ROLE

Tuesday 15 November 2011 Continue reading

Posted in Whitehall | Leave a comment

Greek Deficit and Tax Evasion

One issue that keeps coming up around the Greek crisis is the degree of tax evasion. In the slide below I report the average Greek budget deficit per year on a decade by decade basis since the 1960s (figures on the left – calculated from OECD figures in an excellent paper you can find here). Continue reading

Posted in International, Political Economy, Politics, Public Administration, Spending | 2 Comments

Theresa May: déjà vu all over again

[I appeared briefly on Newsnight commenting on this - the item is about 20 mins in].

A British Home Secretary faces a media firestorm over a major blunder in one of the Home Office’s Executive Agencies. A senior agency official is blamed to shift attention away from Ministers. He resigns and hits back, hard and sues the Home Office and wins.

Theresa May (Home Secretary) and  Brodie Clarke (UK Borders Agency)? Well yes, but it could also be Michael Howard (Home Secretary) and Derek Lewis (Director General of the Prison Service) back in 1995. Continue reading

Posted in Politics, Public Management, Whitehall | 1 Comment