Blog Stats
- 165,063 hits

Colin Talbot is professor of government at the University of Manchester. He writes 'Whitehall Watch' in a personal capacity.
Colin’s Tweets
- RT @Puffles2010: @ShodanAlexM @colinrtalbot @Paulflynnmp @halfon4harlowMP @J__Stephen @CamPubPol Puffles (*points*) adragonsbestfriend.wordpress.com/2013/05/20/a-p… … 1 hour ago
- RT @PCollinsTimes: Gay marriage is a Bill that creates happiness and costs nothing and Yvette Cooper and Ed Miliband deserve credit for ens… 3 hours ago
- RT @JosephWolves: Where they keep @daraobriain and @ProfBrianCox in between series of Stargazing Live. http://t.co/OIcXlrG0dR 23 hours ago
- Can I coin the term #ToryEuroshambles or has someone already thought of it? 1 day ago
Colin’s latest book
Comment is free…
Please feel free to comment and especially to add your own analyses or experiences. Just click on a blog and go to the comment section at the bottom. Or you can email me at colin.talbot@mbs.ac.ukTop Posts
- Visions of Subsidiarity and the Curse of the British Political Tradition
- The Answer to Life, The Universe and Everything? It’s 43.
- Lies, Damned Lies and Government misuse of official statistics: Select Committee Attacks Government
- Lord O'Donnell Suggests .... that someone rather like him should be put in charge of vetting government policy. Seriously?
- The Scrutiny of Public Spending: Margaret Hodge, Robert Chote, and Amyas Morse, amongst others, to discuss how Britain manages public money.
- UKIP: Building a Party when the "Party" is Over?
- Why Spending Review 2013?
- Co-Evolution of the Development of Public Administration, Democracy and Capitalism
- Spending Review 2013 – politics trumps planning, again.
- The UK in 2013: A Failing Economy or a Failing State?
Discussion
- colinrtalbot on Visions of Subsidiarity and the Curse of the British Political Tradition
- Brat on Lord O’Donnell Suggests …. that someone rather like him should be put in charge of vetting government policy. Seriously?
- Inquisitive Practitioner on Lord O’Donnell Suggests …. that someone rather like him should be put in charge of vetting government policy. Seriously?
- Chris Wilson on UKIP: Building a Party when the “Party” is Over?
- brian carr on UKIP: Building a Party when the “Party” is Over?
Tags
Audit Commission banking banks book review broadband CAA carers Children's services Civil Service CPA crisis debt Departments DWP efficiency equality government happiness jargon joined up local government media memes Ministers NAO nationalisation NHS Nudge parliament pay performance PFI policy public services Public Value railways reform Select Committees shadow economy social services spending strategy targets Westminister WhitehallMeta
Category Archives: Public Administration
Visions of Subsidiarity and the Curse of the British Political Tradition
by Martin Smith (York University), Dave Richards and Patrick Diamond (both Manchester University) There is little doubt that the previous Labour Administration and the current Coalition Government have discernibly different governing projects. Despite a rhetorical appeal to the contrary, Labour … Continue reading
Lies, Damned Lies and Government misuse of official statistics: Select Committee Attacks Government
I reproduce here the Press Release issued today by the Public Administration Select Committee – it speaks for itself. Here is the link to the actual Report: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201314/cmselect/cmpubadm/77/77.pdf
Posted in Accountability, Public Administration, Whitehall
Leave a comment
Lord O’Donnell Suggests …. that someone rather like him should be put in charge of vetting government policy. Seriously?
Lord O’Donnell, former head of the civil service, has put forward some ideas for better scrutiny of proposed government policies. According to a report in Civil Service World: Among ideas to prevent “bad policies” from being introduced, [O’Donnell] said a … Continue reading
Posted in Accountability, Parliament, Public Administration, Spending, Whitehall
2 Comments
The Scrutiny of Public Spending: Margaret Hodge, Robert Chote, and Amyas Morse, amongst others, to discuss how Britain manages public money.
We are organising a series of debates and discussions about how Britain manages public money.
Posted in Accountability, Parliament, Public Administration, Spending, Whitehall
1 Comment
Top Twenty Whitehall Watch blog posts
Here’s the top twenty Whitehall Watch blog posts (so far) and the number of views. This doesn’t include numbers for posts that have been republished by Public Finance, Public Servant, LSE Policy and Politics and the Huffington Post.
Reforming the Senior Civil Service – what do you think?
The #GreatWestCoastRailShambles has raised again the issue of the competence, or otherwise, of the Senior Civil Service. Ministers are blaming the mess purely on civil servants, whilst others are pointing to a flawed policy. Without a lot more information, it’s … Continue reading
Posted in Public Administration, Public Management, Whitehall
25 Comments
Romney tells Secret Service detail to “go and get a real job” – well, not really but that’s what he implied…
[President Obama] “took office without the basic qualification that most Americans have, and one that was essential to the task at hand. He had almost no experience working in a business. Jobs to him are about government.” Mitt Romney in … Continue reading
Targets? What targets? Change and Continuity in the performance regime in Whitehall
We were told, when the new Coalition Government came to be, that it would put an end to “New Labour targetry”. The use of targets for public sector performance had become a bête noir of both Conservatives and Liberal Democrats in … Continue reading
Posted in Performance, Politics, Public Administration, Public Management, Whitehall
7 Comments
Co-Evolution of the Development of Public Administration, Democracy and Capitalism
Philipp Krause has raised some very interesting issues about the development of public finance institutions in emerging economies (which are equally applicable to wider public administration capacity development in emerging countries).
G4S and rethinking public services: going beyond ‘one size fits all’
guest post by John Alford and Janine O’Flynn The G4S fiasco surrounding security for the London Olympics has sparked debate about the problems of contracting out. In a new book, John Alford and Janine O’Flynn argue for a broader approach … Continue reading
policy@manchester launches
Public policy community comes together 12 Jul 2012 The University of Manchester has established Policy@Manchester as a network bringing together a range of academics working in a variety of public policy areas.
The Civil Service Reform Plan – Mostly Old Wine in Very Old, but relabelled, Bottles.
The Civil Service Reform Plan announced yesterday mostly rehashes old solutions, some sensible, others of dubious worth – but mostly renames stuff and proclaims it as if it was ‘new’. The cry of ‘cultural change’, for example, towards greater managerial … Continue reading
Posted in Performance, Politics, Public Administration, Public Management, Whitehall
4 Comments
Surpluses, Budgets, Parliament, and Accountability Down Under (Australia): some random thoughts
I am in Australia as “Accenture-Crawford School Distinguished Visiting Professor” at Australian National University in Canberra. Many thanks to both Accenture and the excellent Crawford School of Public Policy. I’ve been doing a fascinating series of meetings, seminars and lectures … Continue reading
The Class Ceiling – Posh Boys (and Girls) Still Rule OK
When Tory MP Nadine Dorries described her Prime Minister and Chancellor as ”two arrogant posh boys” it prompted me to start thinking about my own experiences of class in British society over the past half century. My conclusion – there … Continue reading
Posted in Political Economy, Politics, Public Administration, Whitehall
5 Comments
Jeremy Hunt (DCMS) debacle raises again the issue of Civil Service Reform
This week saw an extraordinary outburst from the most recently retired Head of the Civil Service, Lord Gus O’Donnell. He said, on the BBC, “”When governments go through difficult patches you are looking for who you can blame. The issue … Continue reading
The Public Government of Public Money – not yet, not by a long way
Three decades ago two American academics published a superb analysis of the way in which British government’s made finance decisions provocatively entitled “The Private Government of Public Money” (Heclo and Wildavsky, 1981). Has the Coalition accidentally given birth to … Continue reading
Posted in Parliament, Politics, Public Administration, Spending, Whitehall
1 Comment
Saint GP. Why have GPs been elevated to special status in the health debate?
The whole NHS reform is based on an assertion – that GPs are somehow better placed to decide what NHS services need to be provided because they are in some sense ”closer to patients”. The news story today that GPs … Continue reading
Posted in NHS, Politics, Public Administration, Public Management
9 Comments
Is the Civil Service Accountable to Parliament? Hodge vs O’Donnell spat opens a can of worms.
Is the Civil Service accountable to parliament? Margaret Hodge MP, the formidable chair of the powerful Public Accounts Committee of Parliament says “yes”. Sir (now Lord) Gus O’Donnell and other ex-Mandarins say firmly “no”. (For details see the Guardian website here). … Continue reading
Localism: ‘It’s like letting go of your toddler’s bike’ says Mandarin
Dame Helen Ghosh DCB is, I’m sure, a very fine civil servant in may ways, but sensitive to others perspectives she’s clearly not. Speaking at the NAO Conference on Performance yesterday (22 Feb 2012) Dame Helen was explaining how the … Continue reading
Posted in Public Administration, Whitehall
1 Comment
Lies, Damned Lies, and Government ‘Efficiency’ Savings (Again)
It is nice to see that the new lot are just the same as the old lot, at least when it comes to reporting so-called “efficiency” or “waste” savings. Today Cabinet Office Minister Francis Maude was telling anyone who would … Continue reading
Posted in Performance, Public Administration, Spending, Whitehall
1 Comment
